Fisch Badges: The 12 Hardest, Ranked by Roblox's Own Data
TL;DR: The hardest badge you can still earn is Bestiary: The Deep (64,043 players), almost tied with Bestiary: Astral Observatory (64,236). Skip chasing Bestiary: Animals First Sea and Gone Fishing... Live!: Roblox showed 0 new holders for either in a day. For FischFright, Haunted Skies only needs you in the server when a Jack-o-Moon starts.
64,043. That is how many players hold Bestiary: The Deep, the rarest of the Fisch badges by Roblox's own data, read at 07:17 UTC on October 24, 2026. Fisch has 64 badges, and most of the hard ones are the same kind of task: catch every fish in one place. Two of the top three had no new holders at all in the day before our read, so if you are badge hunting, start with the ones Roblox is still handing out.
Checked Oct 24 from Roblox's badge data for Fisch. How-to steps come from two fan wikis and are marked.
Key Takeaways
- Rarest overall: Bestiary: The Deep, 64,043 players at 07:17 UTC on Oct 24.
- Closest second: Bestiary: Astral Observatory, 64,236, only 193 players more.
- 0 new holders in a day: Bestiary: Animals First Sea (207,540) and Gone Fishing... Live! (319,322), both limited badges.
- 5 badges have a Roblox win rate that rounds to 0.0, and 13 more rounded to 0.001 on Oct 24 (15 on Oct 25).
- New for FischFright 3: The Pumpking (555,311 on Oct 24, 627,235 a day later) and Haunted Skies (402,369, then 460,805).
- Reward: every Bestiary badge comes with a Bobber cosmetic, per Fischipedia.
Overview: how we ranked the Fisch badges
Fisch is a fishing game by Fisching, a Roblox group with 6,180,724 members on Oct 24. The description promises "rare and unique fish, each with 400,000+ possible variations". It was 16th on Roblox's Top Playing Now list when we read it at 07:11 UTC that day, with 72,791 players, and its Roblox name was "Fisch 🎃 [FISCHFRIGHT]". After an update at 16:18 UTC that day, the name read "Fisch 👻 [HORSEMAN]".
Roblox publishes three numbers per badge: how many players have earned it, how many earned it in the past day, and a win rate (winRatePercentage). Roblox does not explain how that win rate is worked out, so we sort by it, then break ties by total holders. Fewer holders means rarer. Roblox reports win rates to three decimals, so five Fisch badges show 0.0.
Desk note: a "past day" of 0 is the giveaway for a dead badge. Bestiary: Animals First Sea and Gone Fishing... Live! both showed 0, while even the rarest live badge, The Deep, picked up 433 new holders that day. That is under 1% of its total, so it is not getting easier fast.
How-to text comes from Roblox's own badge descriptions where the developer wrote one. Several Bestiary badges have no description, so for those we use Fischipedia (fischipedia.org), a community wiki, and the Fisch wiki on Fandom, both unofficial.
The 12 hardest Fisch badges, ranked
Numbers are Roblox's, read at 07:17 UTC on Oct 24 ("past day" is the day before we checked).
1. Bestiary: The Deep (64,043; 433 in the past day). Roblox's text: "You have caught every fish in the The Deep!" Created in July 2026. Fischipedia says it was added in version 1.96.0 and gives the Master Relay Bobber. Do not mix it up with Bestiary: The Depths, an older badge with 6,220,999 holders.
2. Bestiary: Animals First Sea (207,540; 0). No description on Roblox. Fischipedia: "Complete the Animals - Sea 1 Bestiary during the Animal Hunt event." Roblox shows the badge was created in April 2025. With 0 new holders, treat it as gone.
3. Gone Fishing... Live! (319,322; 0). Roblox: "Help a streamer fix strange bugs by catching special fish, reeling in the Clout Carp, and repairing a machine!" Created in February 2026. Fischipedia files it under Twitch Rivals as a limited badge: "Complete the quests from the Twitch Viewer and Streamer."
4. Bestiary: Atlantis (635,286; 371). No description on Roblox. The Fandom wiki says Atlantis "was added on January 25, 2025, with update 1.15.0", that "The Gate to Atlantis is located in the Grand Reef", and that "Atlantis has the most fish in a single bestiary page. (Not counting the All bestiary category)." Getting in takes a chain of quests, per the wiki, so this badge is two grinds in one.
5. Chilled Revelation (2,796,750; 190). "You were in a server during the start of a Frost Moon. [Fischmas Exclusive]". Created in December 2025. It is a luck badge, not a skill badge: you only need to be there when the Frost Moon starts. 190 players still got it in the day before, and Roblox's data does not say how.
6. Bestiary: Astral Observatory (64,236; 621). "You have caught every fish from the Astral Observatory!" Created in August 2026. Reward: the Comet Bobber, per Fischipedia. It has the second-fewest holders of any badge, but a higher win rate than the five above.
7. Bestiary: Skycrest (99,518; 687). "You have caught every fish from Skycrest!" Created in September 2026. Reward: Sky Crystal.
8. Bestiary: Drylands (189,924; 740). "You have caught every fish at the Drylands!" Created in July 2026, version 1.91.0 per Fischipedia. Reward: Small Cactus.
9. Bestiary: Ancient Isle (751,905; 1,169). "You've discovered all the Fish in Ancient Isle!"
10. Bestiary: Blue Moon First Sea (783,030; 920). No description. The Fandom wiki says the Blue Moon "can be summoned by using a Blue Moon Totem or waiting for the season to be Winter, and the weather to be Clear." Fischipedia's events list gives it about 10 minutes. You need every Blue Moon fish, so expect several moons.
11. Bestiary: Frigid Cavern (799,657; 933). No description. Fischipedia says it came in version 1.11.0 with Cryogenic Canal and Glacial Grotto.
12. Bestiary ; Glacial Grotto (831,502; 860). Yes, Roblox lists it with a semicolon. No description.
Image: Fisch on Roblox (Fisching thumbnail)
GODEEPER: New to the rod and the reel bar? Our beginner guide covers casting, shaking and the first islands. Fisch Beginner Guide: How to Fish and FischFright 3 Dates →
Just outside the top 12
These also round to 0.001. Sorted by fewest players:
| Badge | What Roblox says | Players (Oct 24) |
|---|---|---|
| Bestiary: Cryogenic Canal | (no description) | 1,150,654 |
| Sunlit Paradise | "You were in a server during the start of a Tropical Sun. [Fischfest Exclusive]" | 1,409,427 |
| Bestiary: Brine Pool | "You have caught every fish in Brine Pool!" | 1,657,251 |
| Bestiary: Ancient Archives | "Completed the Ancient Archives Bestiary" | 1,860,494 |
| Bestiary: Grand Reef | "You've completed the Grand Reef bestiary! What lies beneath it?" | 5,028,897 |
| Bestiary: Atlantean Storm | "Complete the Atlantean Storm Bestiary!" | 5,448,184 |
The oddest number on the list: Bestiary: Everything ("You have caught every fish!") has 1,539,664 holders, 24 times as many as The Deep. Roblox's data cannot tell us whether Everything still asks for the newer areas. And 10,000 Catches, whose text is "This is 100% Impossible.. Right?", has 4,175,948 holders. Not impossible, then.
Image: Fisch on Roblox (Fisching thumbnail)
FischFright badges and what badges give you
FischFright 3. Two Halloween badges are live. The Pumpking ("Earned via completing the Pumpkin King's questline in FischFright 3!") was created Oct 17 and had 555,311 holders. Haunted Skies ("You were in a server during the start of a Jack-o-Moon. [FischFright Exclusive]") was created Sep 23 and had 402,369.
Desk note: our FischFright guide counted 275,764 Haunted Skies holders on October 21. By our Oct 24 read it was 402,369, a jump of 126,605. The Pumpking added 61,909 in the day before our read. A re-read at about 03:55 UTC on Oct 25 had The Pumpking at 627,235 and Haunted Skies at 460,805. These two are the fastest-growing badges on the list, so play them before the event ends.
Our FischFright 3 guide has the event dates, the 11 rituals and the Pumpkin King steps.
Rewards. Fischipedia: "These badges are granted upon completing certain pages of the Bestiary. Each badge has an associated Bobber cosmetic reward." Other badges carry titles or boats; its example is Santa's Helper, which gives a Snow Globe Bobber, a title and a Sleigh boat.
Counting. Roblox listed 64 badges for Fisch on Oct 24. Fischipedia says "There are 90 badges in Fisch", and the Fandom page counts fewer. Our Fisch badges page shows Roblox's live list, refreshed daily.
Image: Fisch on Roblox (Fisching thumbnail)
For parents. Roblox labels Fisch Minimal, "Suitable for everyone". On Oct 24 the store had 9 game passes for sale, from "Emote Pack" and "Bobber Pack" (99 Robux each) to "Appraise Anywhere" (499), and more than 150 developer products, including "2X Luck - 1 Hour" (59). No badge on this list needs Robux. Roblox's Parental Controls let a parent "set a monthly spending limit on how much money your child can spend on Roblox".
Our take
Go for The Pumpking and Haunted Skies now, then pick one Bestiary area and finish it. The two FischFright badges added 61,909 and 44,815 holders in a day, so they are the quickest wins. The Deep and Astral Observatory sit at about 64,000 holders each, which makes them the real long grinds. Skip Animals First Sea and Gone Fishing... Live!: 0 new holders in a day. What we don't know yet: whether Chilled Revelation's 190 daily holders mean Frost Moons still happen outside Fischmas.
Our view, from the sources in this article.
GODEEPER: Badge hunting in a scarier game? Our DOORS ranking uses the same Roblox numbers. Hardest DOORS Badges: 16 Rare Ones You Can Still Earn →
How we checked this
We read all 64 of Fisch's badges from Roblox's public badges API through a mirror at 07:17 UTC on Oct 24, plus the game data, group, age label, game passes and developer products. Rank and player count come from Roblox's Top Playing Now chart, read at 07:11 UTC that day. Steps, rewards, version numbers and event details come from Fischipedia and the Fisch wiki on Fandom, both unofficial; two Fandom pages blocked our reader. The October 21 Haunted Skies count comes from our FischFright 3 guide. The Arctic Shift archive timed out on Oct 24, so there is no Reddit quote in this guide. We did not play the game. All 34 sources are in our source file. Last reviewed October 24, 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Fisch badge has the fewest players? Bestiary: The Deep, 64,043 on Oct 24.
How many badges are there? Roblox listed 64 on Oct 24.
Do Bestiary badges give anything? A Bobber cosmetic each, per Fischipedia.
Is Gone Fishing... Live! still earnable? Roblox showed 0 new holders in a day, so likely not.
Where can I see live badge numbers? On our Fisch badges page, refreshed daily.
Related Reading
- Hardest Badges in 99 Nights in the Forest: 12 Rarest Ranked: the same ranking method for a survival game.
- Fish It Roblox Guide: Rods, Islands and the Halloween Update: the other big fishing game on the chart.
- Most Played Roblox Games Right Now: Top 25 by Live Players: where Fisch sits among the biggest games.
References
Keep reading
FischFright 3: The Pumpking Badge, 11 Rituals and Nov 9 End
Game Guides · 6 min
Fisch Beginner Guide: How to Fish and FischFright 3 Dates
Game Guides · 6 min
Hardest DOORS Badges: 16 Rare Ones You Can Still Earn
Game Guides · 9 min
Hardest Badges in 99 Nights in the Forest: 12 Rarest Ranked
Game Guides · 8 min
Sol's RNG Beginner Guide: Auras, Biomes, Luck and Gear
Game Guides · 7 min
Violence District Halloween 2026: Butcher, Ranked, Nov 21
Game Guides · 7 min
Slap Battles Halloween 2026: Revenant Glove and Nov 6 End
Game Guides · 9 min
Fling Things and People Guide: Grabbing, Plots and Passes
Game Guides · 7 min
About the author
The ObbyDesk desk
We read the update notes, check Roblox's own numbers, do the math and tell you what's worth your time. We don't play-test games for our articles, and when we can't confirm something, we say so.
Independent, no ads
ObbyDesk is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Roblox Corporation or any game developer, and nobody pays for coverage. There are no ads and no affiliate links. Codes come only from the developer's own channels. We write with AI tools and match every fact to its source before it goes up. Prices, odds and event dates change with updates, so check the game itself before you spend Robux. More on our independence, how we check and how we use AI.